The actual scarf looks a bit off from the original design, it resembles more of a long face towel that's been flung around the neck instead of an actual scarf that wraps around the neck like in the concept art.
Isn't it our duty to closely capture the design presented to us by our concept artists and not just go with something that seems ''okay''? No offense to the way that you did it. I learned a lot from this, I'm just wondering why we didn't try and make it look more like the design?