54 replies ·
posted April 7, 2021 5:50am
This is an on-going thread documenting my progress through the 2021 Collab Project.
Week 1 - Wip - Lanterns -First Day
I'm not quite happy yet.Some changes still neededI am also not sure if the wall-supporter (don´t know the name) is one piece or a curved one.But this is such a tiny piece. I guess it is useful to keep it simple and do not use more vertices than necessary.Also it seems the proportion of the lantern is a litte bit longer.Have to lock at this with fresh eyes in the morning;)Or are here are people with a better artist-eye?
Looking good. Maybe make some different variations, put them next to each other and decide which one to go with.
This is great! I think you might be right about the proportions. As lucky said make a variation, duplicate it and lengthen the body of the lantern a little bit. I don't think you're far off.
Thanks for the feedback.You are right, I also was thinking about some variations for a better comparison.This was a try to fit the artwork, it is hardly to see. But this version doesn`t speak to me, there is no character for my feeling.Not really a low-poly, stylized character.So, today I will try another way. Maybe using the Lattice Modifier to play with proportions.
Week1- Wip-Lanterns- Day 2
Left Version Day 01more rounded, more density overall, perhaps proportion not exactly like the artworkand a little bit boring, I thinkMiddle and Right are the same objectI changed the shape of the body (middle-part) with a lattice modifierless geometry, more squarr edgedI also changed these wall-supporter thingie, little bit curved now
I am not sure about these versions yet. Maybe I`ll get another idea over night ;)
Just discovered some mistakes. Some clean-ups are needed. Also I am thinking about some e.g screws. Not sure how detailed I should go with the lanterns.
Street lights also could be useful for the saveness of the ways.... (just mumble to myself)
nice work on them , they look great. as for the details i have no clue myself since its low poly , for that the Teamleaders or Kent will be better ;-)
mmonaloren screws can baked as normal maps later.
Like shown here for instance:
Think of your lantern as being completely black (flat shaded, so no lighting information). That way you only see the contours. That should be your low poly model. Adding detail that doesn't change the contour should be done with normal maps.
At least that is how I understand it, but I am pretty new to this style ;)
Nice example spikeyxxx . I had something like this in mind.I guess as well there is a difference between low-poly and stylized style.
In the artwork, the lantern appears very round. (I had a little trouble with the top part). However, it is also very small.I think there are still too many loops on the top for low poly. I made the bottom with less loops, just to try.I have little experience with the workflow sculpting and normal map. In addition to screws and dents, can edges etc. look more rounded due to a normal map? I assume it will work for the body, but the top shape is nearly a half-sphere.I will have to try it;)
I`ve found references for stylized laterns, but mostly square ones.But it seems, that it is usual to use a bevel.Just some examples. And the other img shows our own lantern. At the wall and in the garden.(btw. also with blue light ;) ) There are also the body rounded.
I will have a look at the normal map course on CG cookie for some hints.
Normal Map Modeling
At the end - learning by doing;)
In a few weeks time, you will be an expert on low poly modeling and Normal Map Baking ;)
Homework Submission - Week 1 - lantern
After trying a few verions I decided for another one as my final for week 01.At the artwork it looks like it is a 8-sided lantern and very rounded. However, I used 6-sides for my version.I guess after working forward with normal mapping etc. it will look like a rounded one from the camera perspektiv,because the lanterns are not so huge.At the moment there are separate parts: body,top, bottom and the wall-support.So there are still a few vertices and faces who can be reduced.For the body and top I used a lattice modifier so I´m still flexible with the shape.
about 532 Vertices/ 1043 Tris
Excellent WIP thread mmonaloren! Great result too, especially considering how little reference you have to go on (low resolution in the art). You've easily earned full points this week 👍
My only note is there seems to be an imbalance of polygons. Some areas have too few polys while others have too many. If you don't mind, I'd like to use your lantern to explain during the stream tomorrow. If that's OK can you upload your .blend file to this directory within the project files? SPICE-VENDORS-HOUSE/SCENES/MODELS/TEMP
Great block out Mona. Awesome idea with the latice. Working smarter not harder. Keep it up, looking forward to next week.
nice shape and great amount of verticies i think :)
thank you for the feedback. I really appreciate that you provide detailed feedback to everyone. Especially with the high number of participants in the project .
Some areas have too few polys while others have too many
Caught me ;) I noticed it too later after looking again and again at the lantern that the polycount is not really constant.In the meantime I changed some areas. I was really often not sure how many are necessary and altered the model often.It is okay if you like to use this as an example.
I am new to google-drive, so I am not sure if I got it right with the settings to give access.I right-clicked and got some settings, not very self-explanatory. Hope it works.
Btw. I used a lot more refernces to work with to get an idea of stylized-style of lanterns.Often they are more in a phantasy-style. I tend to use too much references and getting confused on the way.I really have to find a golden middle-way to make my decisions.
mmonaloren This has been a great read. I love what you are doing and the results are marvelous!
week2 - day 1 : GoogleDrive Day
At least I was able to persuade GoogleDrive to syn.--CheckMy way for troubleshooting if sync won´t work:-Click on the TrayIcon (Back-Up-Sync GoogleDrive)- Find the Settings on the upper right side- Exit BackUp&Sync and Re-Startthen it began to work immediately
Now I have to figure out how to these folders&files to work withDo we have a info.txt or something with notes about how we have to named our filesand the rules how to work with the folders & files?This would be very helpful.
My understanding is for the first step:We are each working with our own Wip filedirectory: Spice-Vendors-House/SCENES/MODELS/WIP/ACCESSORES_ACC_Housefile: WIPP_acc_lantern_monaloren_xx.blend
this will go later to an corresponding " xxxxx.master.blend"the collection of each master.blend would be linked to a "xxxxmaster.assembly"
So far I have only to take care of my "xxxx Wip-file"Hopefully this is the right way.
Sadly it takes me a lot of time, so no Blender work today for me.But had more than one look to the recommended courses.I`m learning far more than just Blender in this Collab :)
(one of them is patience with setting up and working with various tools and to handle these in two languages :))
week 2- day 2 Redone Homework Submission week1clean-up the model of week 1 and made a Low-Poly Version - according to Submission feedback and lifestreamVersion 1 - Left side - Version according to the lifestreamVerson 2 - Right side- My Changes
Changes1.Reduce the distance between the wall and the lamp-body. For a more realistic proportion.2. Removed the top edge from the body. I found there is no additional edge necessary and there wasn't one at the bottom at all.The parts can also be connected to one another in this way3. Change the Bottom of the bodyI honestly like it more this way. The Connection and so the silhouette looks much more smoother and pleasing for my tasteI also changed the part underneath so there is a better connection and deleted some edges.
Overall I was able so save some more Vertices.
But I will try another version:Vadim mentioned during the Lifestream that the top of the lantern was not supposed to be so roundedrather as an octagon with faces.Because of the conceptart I already thought it could be a 8-sided one.
So I`ll model another Low-Poly version according to Vadims inspiration.
Great effort you put in writing everything down. Also nice improvements on the lamp.
Looking good mmonaloren 👍
And here it is: the octagon version according to Vadims advice
actuelly less tris-I forgot to delete a face.
I like this version. Looks very similar to the conceptart I guess
Very clean and accurate work! Great job mmonaloren ! Can't wait to see your sculpting interpretation! :)
Great work Mona, looks like you're ready for sculpting your high rez :)
week 2 Day 3/4-practice sculpting
thats my result so far. Took some time to get used to sculping. Fortunately, Kent demonstrated the lantern in the stream. Got problems with the holder and has to start all over. In addition, details are still missing.But overall I am very happy. Slowly get a feel for the brushes. But now I need a break first.There is still a lot to be done
hardly anything to see on the screenshot-hmm-and I thought it could be too much
Nice start but I think you may be to cautious with your brush strokes. Try to use the scrape brush with more strength to get beter contrast in your geometry.
Thank you for your advice lucky. Very helpful. I think you are right. I was little bit too carefully the first time.It looks like this at the moment.
week2-day 5 - more sculpting
Kent said at some point in the stream the brush shouldn´t be too strong and in the normal map course is recommended to exaggerate scultping for a clear normal map.The challenge would be to find the working middle way and to be constant in the details.I tried to simulate rust at some edges with the voronoi. I kind of like that ;).At the body I also bended the glass frame a little bit, and rust of course.More noticeable this time, I guess? Is this enough?At the handle I ran into another problem. See next post.
Looks beter already, maybe breaking up the edges of the top even more, I still have the feeling I'm looking at a wireframe if you know what mean. Maybe putting some deep dents in the edges.
week2- day 5 -little troubleshoting
I always run into problems with ugly distortions expecially on the handle.I did this part several times, smooth brush did´t help, I relaxed the edges by hand and try a lot more, but nothing worked.It was strange because the density on the edges are similar e.g to the top part and also Kent did not have this problem in the stream.
only one example
Yesterday was a discussion about normal maps and distortion etc. in the wip-thread of lexicolopolis . At this time I still haven´t seen any conjunction with my distortion problem. But there had to be one. Something that made Kent different. After sleeping some hours I finally had the idea.
I have made a test unwrapping on the Low-Poly parts. Not very clean and final, only as a test.Copy the Low-Poly to made the High-Poly part.So my dirty UV-Map was copied too. The seams were also not set cleanly and there were some issues.And the distortions are exactly where I set these nasty seams.
Could be so easy. So, I delete the Seams and UV map from the High-Poly and hopefully it will work now.First tests are promising.
Totally forgot that there were these test unwrapping. Was so concentrated on sculpting ;)Should have much more time to practice all the sculpt. But I am running out of time today. There is a deadline;)However I will try my best to get a decent result. I have a lot of fun sculpting the lantern.
To me it looks like it could be one of these things: an extra edge that is hiding under the real edge, some other geometric issue on seam, sharp edges not being in optimal places, smooth vertex being set at too low an angle. Those are my guesses anyway. :D
Yes -it was an overall nasty unwrapp and bad setting of seems e.g. sharp edges in the wrong place and missing edge in the loop.
As I said I had completely forgotten about it. Short way - simple delete ;) Time is precious - haha.
Homework Submission - Week 2 - lantern
This was an intersting and exiting week of sculpting. I had a lot of fun. But now I´m running out of time and I have to call it finished.
At least for this week. There is a lot to improve.
First I tried to get familar with the behavior of the brushes (and working with graphic pen of course).Then I used the voronoi, scrape and crease in these order part by part of the lantern.
I also used the voronoi to simulate rust. Mostly in the edges.I had a lot of respect for the details, and did these steps at the end.
I had some trouble with distortions but could solve most of it and I am not so happy with the glass and will definitely change it.There is so much more I could do and need much more practice, but for now, I am happy to got it to this point.
(Note:made changes in the meantime -see screen on next post, and syn. with GoogleDrive)
Your sculpt turned out beautifully mmonaloren! I'm so happy to read that you enjoyed the process. Sculpting will always be one of my favorite 3D tasks.
No constructive criticism from me. Just keep doing what you're doing 👍